GuidesGuide
Crew holds explained: first hold, second hold, challenge
A hold is a promise from the crew member. They agree to come to you before taking other work on your dates. In return you owe them a quick answer when challenged and a release the day you know you won't use them. This is how it works on US commercial jobs, and how the UK, Australia and New Zealand write the same rules down.
Last checked November 2026
Availability check, hold and booking
Crewing a job moves through three stages. Each asks more of both sides, so name the stage every time you write to someone.
- Availability check. You ask whether someone is free on certain dates. Nobody commits to anything. Name the job, the dates and whether it is bidding or awarded. Wording is in the availability check email.
- Hold. The crew member agrees not to take conflicting work without coming to you first. You have not hired them, and in most US deals you owe them nothing yet.
- Booking. You have hired them for those dates at an agreed rate. From here, cancelling usually costs money.
Some producers say soft hold when the job may not happen and firm hold when it almost certainly will. Both work like an ordinary hold. The label only tells the crew member how much to count on it. Australian booking guidelines ask you to call it a quote hold while the job is unawarded and a light hold when the dates are likely to move.
If the job is still bidding, say so in the hold. Better still, check availability without holding until the award is close. See checking crew before a bid is awarded.
First hold, second hold and what order means
Order follows when each hold was placed. The first hold has first call on the dates. A second hold means the person is already held elsewhere and you are next in line if that hold releases. Some crew will give a third.
A second hold is worth less than it looks. If the first holder books, you are out, and not everyone will tell you. In Motionographer's 2019 interviews with about 30 freelance motion designers in Chicago, New York and Los Angeles, about 45 percent said they always tell the second hold when the first books. The rest do it sometimes or never. Ask where you stand, and keep a backup moving.
Holds are per person and per date. A gaffer can be on your first hold for the 14th and on another company's first hold for the 15th. If your dates move, don't assume your place moves with them. Tell the crew member that day and ask where you stand on the new dates.
The challenge: confirm or release
A challenge happens when someone further down the line wants to book. The crew member, or their agent, goes back to the first holder and asks them to book or release. UK and Australian diary services call this a push to confirm. The Screen Guild in New Zealand calls it a confirm or release request.
Some markets put a clock on it. The Screen Guild's guidance gives the first pencil holder 24 hours from the request, with extra time over weekends and public holidays: a request at 4pm Friday can be answered by 10am Monday. Booking guidelines from the Australian agencies Top Techs, Auscrew and Freelancers Promotions also give 24 hours. Freelancers says the hold is released if the production doesn't call back in that time.
In the US the window is custom. We found no guild or union rule that sets one for commercial crew holds. About a day is the usual expectation. Most of Motionographer's interviewees treated a challenge at 5pm Friday as expiring at 5pm Monday, and about a quarter said 5pm Saturday. If a weekend is involved, agree the deadline out loud.
When you are challenged, book the person or release them. Asking for a few more hours because the client has not signed off is fair once. Letting the deadline pass and expecting the hold to stand is not. Wording for both replies is in the hold, booking and release emails.
Terms by market
| Stage | US commercial | UK, Australia, New Zealand | Production commits to | Crew member commits to |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Availability check | Avail check | Enquiry, availability check | Nothing | An honest answer |
| First hold | First hold, soft or firm hold | First pencil (UK, NZ), first hold, quote hold or light hold (Australia) | In the US, nothing binding. In Australian and NZ guidelines, answering a challenge within 24 hours, and the hold confirms itself if not released before the shoot | Not taking conflicting work without offering you the dates first |
| Second hold | Second hold | Second pencil, subsequent hold | Nothing | Often, telling you if the first hold releases or books. Practice varies |
| Challenge | Challenge | Push to confirm (UK, Australia), confirm or release (NZ) | Booking or releasing within the agreed window | Giving the first holder that window before accepting other work |
| Booking | Booked, confirmed | Confirmed booking | Paying the agreed rate, and the cancellation terms of the deal or local guidelines if you cancel | Working those dates |
What a booking commits you to
A booking is a hire. The crew member turns down other work for your dates and you owe them the agreed pay. What you owe if you cancel depends on the deal, any union agreement that covers the job, and local custom. There is no single US rule, so write the cancellation terms into the booking.
Published terms elsewhere show the range. The UK's Advertising Producers Association crew terms, as set out in a 2025 APA masterclass, charge no fee at 7 or more days' notice, 50 percent at 6 to 4 days, 75 percent at 3 to 2 days and 100 percent the day before. The Freelancers Promotions guidelines in Victoria charge a full day for a cancelled confirmed booking, waived if the technician picks up other work that day.
Some markets also turn holds into bookings automatically. In New Zealand a pencil becomes a confirmed booking 24 hours before the job starts, or earlier if the crew member starts prep, attends a recce or travels to location. Top Techs and Freelancers Promotions treat a first hold as confirmed if it is not released 2 working days before. We found no US equivalent. But a US producer who holds someone until the night before has still cost them whatever they turned down.
This page describes trade practice and is not legal advice. In a dispute, the deal memo and any union agreement decide it.
When and how to release
Release the day you know you won't use someone. That means the day the bid is lost, the day a shoot day is cut, or the day you pick someone else for the role. Waiting until you are sure about everyone else is how crew end up held for a job they were never going to get.
Release in writing, even if you also call. Name the job and the dates you are letting go. If you are keeping some days, list the ones you still hold. Crew remember the producer who released them a week out, and they remember the one who never released them at all.
Holds through an agent or rep
Many DPs, production designers, stylists and hair and makeup artists have a rep who keeps their calendar. Place the hold with the rep and send challenges and releases the same way. If you agreed a hold with the crew member directly, tell the rep too, or it may not be on the calendar the rep is booking from.
Tell the rep if you are holding more than one person for the same role. Auscrew, Top Techs and Freelancers Promotions all require it, especially when the holds sit with different agents. If you plan to negotiate the rate, say so when you place the hold. Under the Freelancers guidelines, the normal rate applies if you have not negotiated before the crew member accepts.
Mistakes that cost you crew
- Holding several people for one slot. Each extra hold blocks a calendar for a job that person will not get. The Victorian guidelines discourage holding more than one technician per role and say blanket holds need the crew member's express agreement. If you need a backup, tell them they are the backup.
- Never releasing. A hold you forgot about is still a hold to the person who turned down work for it.
- Calling a hold a booking. Booked means hired. If you write that someone is booked when you mean held, expect them to treat it as a hire. Use the words hold and booking and nothing vaguer.
- Holding without details. Give the client, every date including prep and travel, and whether the job is bidding. A hold with no dates or role is easy for the crew member to break.
- Moving the dates again and again. One move is normal. After the second or third, crew plan around you.
Questions
- What is the difference between a first hold and a second hold?
- A first hold has first call on the dates. The crew member will not take conflicting work without offering it to you first. A second hold means they are already held by someone else, and you are next in line if that hold releases.
- How long do I have to answer a challenge?
- In the US there is no written rule. About a day is the usual expectation, so agree the deadline when you are challenged, especially before a weekend. Several Australian and New Zealand guidelines set 24 hours from the request.
- Is a pencil the same as a hold?
- Yes. The UK, Australia and New Zealand say pencil or first pencil where US producers say hold or first hold.
- Does placing a hold commit the production to pay?
- In most US deals, no. The commitment starts at booking, and cancellation terms come from the deal or any union agreement. Some Australian and New Zealand guidelines turn a hold into a booking automatically if it is not released before the shoot.
- When should I release a hold?
- The day you know you will not use the person. That includes a lost bid, a cut shoot day or choosing someone else for the role. Release in writing and name the dates.
Sources
- The Screen Guild (NZ), Booking system: how pencil bookings work
- Top Techs, crew booking guidelines
- Auscrew, bookings guide
- Freelancers Promotions, Victorian crew booking guidelines (July 2025)
- APA masterclass, Crew terms and diary services (February 2025)
- Motionographer, Hold me, I'm scared: your guide to navigating the hold system (2019)
- Wide Angle Productions, Can I put you on hold? (2020)
See who is held on every job
mymark reads your call sheets and crew lists, so you can search everyone you have booked before and see the document each name came from. On each project it tracks where every person stands: Shortlisted, Contacted, Interested, Holding, Booked or Paid. It drafts the outreach emails, and you send them from your own email. It never sees anyone's calendar, so checking who is free is still up to you.